Hello dear
Welcome to Papa's Pizzeria Palmetto
Papa's Pizzeria Palmetto is a culinary gem located at 653 10th St E, Palmetto, FL. Renowned for its Detroit-style deep-dish pizza, this pizzeria delights with perfectly baked crusts, abundant cheese, and rich, flavorful sauces. The menu features an array of delectable options, including mouthwatering wings and fresh salads, all praised for their quality and taste. The inviting atmosphere is complemented by exceptional customer service, where staff go above and beyond to ensure a memorable dining experience. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Papa’s Pizzeria offers unforgettable flavors that will keep you coming back for more.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
About
Papa's Pizzeria Palmetto
Papa's Pizzeria Palmetto is a delightful gem tucked away in Palmetto, Florida, that promises a pizza experience like no other. Located at 653 10th St E, this beloved pizzeria has quickly become a local favorite, boasting rave reviews for its mouthwatering offerings and exceptional service.
From the moment you step in, the inviting atmosphere and the warm smiles from the staff evoke a sense of community. As one customer, Bri Gonzalez, aptly described, the service here is "out of this world." It’s the kind of place where the staff genuinely cares, going the extra mile, such as helping patrons carry their food. Such attention to detail sets the stage for the culinary delights that follow.
Speaking of delights, the menu is a well-curated homage to pizza lovers. One standout option is the Detroit Style Deepdish pizza, which has left many patrons in awe. Manny T. shared his experience of tasting the pizza for the first time, marvelling at the perfectly baked crust, generous cheese, and rich tomato sauce that coalesces into a harmony of flavors. The care that goes into crafting each pie is evident, and it’s no surprise that it elicited such excitement.
Another must-try is the Chicken Florentine Pizza, adored by visitors like Justin Lambert, who raved about its quality alongside the impressive wings. The wings themselves have received accolades for their seasoning, size, and flavor—true testament to the kitchen’s commitment to delivering remarkable dishes. Each bite is a celebration of taste, and the pizzas are loaded with fresh ingredients that speak volumes about Papa's dedication to quality.
For those indulging in a variety of appetizers, the cheese sticks have also garnered glowing reviews, proving that every item on the menu is crafted with the same passion that defines Papa’s Pizzeria. As Emily Bernadine noted, the flavors are nothing short of exceptional, consistently ranking among the best pizza places even for seasoned travelers.
Papa's Pizzeria Palmetto isn’t just another pizza place; it’s a culinary experience that leaves a lasting impression. Whether you’re visiting from out of town or living in the area, the combination of hearty dishes, friendly service, and a genuine sense of hospitality creates an irresistible allure. If you're searching for a pizza haven, look no further—Papa’s is a must-visit that promises to leave you craving more.
With its prime location, call Papa's at +1 941-722-1000 to place an order or come in and savor the magic that awaits. Your taste buds will thank you.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ SO AMAZINGG!! We ordered some wings with 2 pizzas, a salad and everything was made to perfection. The flavor was so good, pizzas were loaded, wings were big also they were seasoned sooo well and the salad was yummy and fresh. Also from the moment I called the shop to place our order till the moment we left, the customer service was out of this world!! They were soo kind and even helped us carry our food out. They deserve 5 stars and more!! 10/10 recommend going to this place, you won’t regret it!! ”
“ This was my first time eating Detroit Style Deepdish pizza so when I try a new place I typically dine in so it’s fresh as can be. While I waited for my pie, the owner “Papa” whom was extremely courteous and knowledgeable (about what makes a pizza great), described to me the difference between, Detroit style and Chicago style...I must admit, I was pretty excited to taste it for myself. Once it was on my table, I thanked Him with a little prayer, and BAM!!! I was blown away! The crust was perfect, the cheese was plenty good and the sauce with tomatoes brought everything together...undeniably worth it. ”
“ We are in town for the SUNMED Owners Conference and stopped by a locals recommendation and it didn’t disappoint. The girls has Chicken Florentine Pizza and I had wings. The pizza was great and wing were big ones and delicious. Michael helped us out and went above and beyond taking care of us. I highly recommend giving this pizza shop a try! ”
“ We were visiting from Ohio & looking for a pizza place and decided to order from here on a whim due to it being so close to us. We try new pizza places all over when we travel & this is honestly some of the best pizza we’ve ever had. It’s in our top 5 of a very long list. We actually got it a second time during our stay. Everything is so flavorful and delicious! The cheese sticks were also amazing! We will be back here again next visit! ”
“ Wth?! This was an awesome pizza find. I came in town for work and I want a simple cheese pizza. I put up my Google map and just did a search for pizza. There were tons around me. I was turned off by the chains ones. Most of the others that came up looked more like a fancy Italian restaurant that happened to make pizza. I just randomly picked this place. It was convenient and closed half an hour later than the other one I wanted to go to. I walked in, whoever was behind the counter with super friendly and greeted me well. I live in Miami nobody does that. Lol I got a large pie 16". I got it togo because I wanted to use the other half for lunch the next day. The crust was thin, just the way I like it. Bottom was chared but not burnt. The cheese mixture was just right and the sauce was enough to be there but not enough to over power or make the crust soggy. A good combination of sweet. Tomatoey, salt, tangy to contast the savory cheese. Best pizza Ive had on the west coast of Florida. Especially if you are into the thin cust New York style pizza. The place was the standard pizza strip plaza place. Nothing special about the ambience but the pizza is fire and service was on point. ”
“ Those that follow my reviews know that we love to find those small tucked away hidden gems and love to support the small businesses trying to make it in a chain driven world. Add to the mix that celebrity pizza reviews from one person in particular are all the rage and know it seems everyone is on the band wagon. Not us. We keep it simple and we review everything and everywhere we go. Wanted pizza for Sunday lunch while we were shopping around Bradenton/Palmetto today and saw this in Google maps just before we left home. Nice to have a pizza place open at 11am on a Sunday. Can't get a warmer more friendly greeting than that of Mr. Jimmy. We ordered up and then got what we sometimes call a "dining experience" First we wanted to sample the wings. Wings are a hit and miss in Florida, and mostly a miss for many that we have tried. Papa's nails them! Perfectly cooked and sauced to perfection. Now for the Za's. I had the "Pig Out" (Ham, Bacon, Pepperoni, and sausage). She had the Buffalo Chicken Pizza. These pizzas are made with the cornmeal dusting, which some people don't care for, but we have no problem with it. Cooked to absolute perfection in our book. Not well done, but not far from it. Gives that nice hint of char, no soggy flop, even with the heavy toppings, and a balance of chew and crispy crunch. The sauce is amazing. The toppings plentiful. That cheese is just the right binder to hold it all together. Perfect bites every time. Now, those living in the area from New York. Stop. Just please stop. Stop whining about no good New York Pizza in Florida. That's because this is Florida not New York. And...NY pie is way over rated. We're originally from Ohio and prefer the Midwest style. Papa's is a perfect balance of Midwest meets East Coast (leaning towards Jersey style). Prices are certainly fine for the times. All in all, this is the 100% absolute best pizza we've had in Florida. After 7 years of living here, we finally found what we like and how we like it, including the wings. Thank you Jimmy for the dining experience and we will see you soon! ”
“ I had seen this place popping up on my Facebook feed and though would give them a try as I was looking for another place to that family owned to enjoy some pizza. I got the 10" was perfect size for me. It had all fresh ingredients could tell they were done in the restaurant. The sauce was fresh and had a good flavor along with decent amount of seasoning. Although the crust was done, I will have them cook just a little longer because the meat and vegetables made it just slightly wet (still enjoyable just my preference) they actually had green olives as I prefer them over the black. I will be back to try some of their other items besides the pizza again. The owner was friendly, place was small and cozy ( I took to go). ”
“ I'm so very impressed. My boyfriend and I were treated so kindly by the owner. His attention to detail was evident in the cleanliness of the dining room and absolutely phenomenal food. The best mozzarella sticks and pizza I've had in a long time. The ingredients were fresh and everything was cooked to perfection. I've never written a Google review, but this place was so impressive. We can't wait to go again. ”